| Message ID | 20210407001502.1890-2-shiraz.saleem@intel.com (mailing list archive) |
|---|---|
| State | Awaiting Upstream |
| Delegated to: | Netdev Maintainers |
| Headers | show |
| Series | Add Intel Ethernet Protocol Driver for RDMA (irdma) | expand |
| Context | Check | Description |
|---|---|---|
| netdev/tree_selection | success | Guessing tree name failed - patch did not apply |
On Tue, Apr 06, 2021 at 07:14:40PM -0500, Shiraz Saleem wrote: > +/* Structure representing auxiliary driver tailored information about the core > + * PCI dev, each auxiliary driver using the IIDC interface will have an > + * instance of this struct dedicated to it. > + */ > +struct iidc_core_dev_info { > + struct pci_dev *pdev; /* PCI device of corresponding to main function */ > + struct auxiliary_device *adev; > + /* KVA / Linear address corresponding to BAR0 of underlying > + * pci_device. > + */ > + u8 __iomem *hw_addr; > + int cdev_info_id; > + > + u8 ftype; /* PF(false) or VF (true) */ Where is ftype initialized? > + u16 vport_id; > + enum iidc_rdma_protocol rdma_protocol; This duplicates the aux device name, not really sure why it is needed. One user just uses it to make the string, the rest is entangled with the devlink and doesn't need to be stored here. > + struct iidc_qos_params qos_info; > + struct net_device *netdev; > + > + struct msix_entry *msix_entries; > + u16 msix_count; /* How many vectors are reserved for this device */ > + > + /* Following struct contains function pointers to be initialized > + * by core PCI driver and called by auxiliary driver > + */ > + const struct iidc_core_ops *ops; > +}; I spent a while trying to understand this struct and why it exists and.. > + > +struct iidc_auxiliary_dev { > + struct auxiliary_device adev; > + struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info; This cdev_info should just be a 'struct ice_pf *' and the "struct iidc_core_dev_info" should be deleted entirely. You'll notice this ends up looking nearly exactly like mlx5 does after this. You can see it clearly based on how this gets initialized: cdev_info->pdev = pf->pdev; cdev_info->hw_addr = (u8 __iomem *)pf->hw.hw_addr; struct ice_vsi *vsi = ice_get_main_vsi(pf); cdev_info->vport_id = vsi->vsi_num; cdev_info->netdev = vsi->netdev; cdev_info->msix_count = pf->num_rdma_msix; cdev_info->msix_entries = &pf->msix_entries[pf->rdma_base_vector]; ice_setup_dcb_qos_info(pf, cdev_info->qos_info); Since the main place this cdev_info appears is in the ops API between the two modules, it looks to me like this is being designed in this obfuscated way to try and create a stable ABI between two modules. Remove all the stable module ABI hackery before you resend it. Jason
> Subject: Re: [PATCH v4 resend 01/23] iidc: Introduce iidc.h > > On Tue, Apr 06, 2021 at 07:14:40PM -0500, Shiraz Saleem wrote: > > +/* Structure representing auxiliary driver tailored information about > > +the core > > + * PCI dev, each auxiliary driver using the IIDC interface will have > > +an > > + * instance of this struct dedicated to it. > > + */ > > +struct iidc_core_dev_info { > > + struct pci_dev *pdev; /* PCI device of corresponding to main function */ > > + struct auxiliary_device *adev; > > + /* KVA / Linear address corresponding to BAR0 of underlying > > + * pci_device. > > + */ > > + u8 __iomem *hw_addr; > > + int cdev_info_id; > > + > > + u8 ftype; /* PF(false) or VF (true) */ > > Where is ftype initialized? Today it is just pf. But the upcoming Intel ethernet VF driver will set it to true. > > > + u16 vport_id; > > + enum iidc_rdma_protocol rdma_protocol; > > This duplicates the aux device name, not really sure why it is needed. One user just > uses it to make the string, the rest is entangled with the devlink and doesn't need > to be stored here. It is used to pass the type of protocol at drv.probe() in aux RDMA driver. > > > + struct iidc_qos_params qos_info; > > + struct net_device *netdev; > > + > > + struct msix_entry *msix_entries; > > + u16 msix_count; /* How many vectors are reserved for this device */ > > + > > + /* Following struct contains function pointers to be initialized > > + * by core PCI driver and called by auxiliary driver > > + */ > > + const struct iidc_core_ops *ops; > > +}; > > I spent a while trying to understand this struct and why it exists and.. > > > + > > +struct iidc_auxiliary_dev { > > + struct auxiliary_device adev; > > + struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info; > > This cdev_info should just be a 'struct ice_pf *' and the "struct iidc_core_dev_info" > should be deleted entirely. You'll notice this ends up looking nearly exactly like > mlx5 does after this. It was intentionally designed to be core device object carving out only pieces of the PF information required by the rdma driver. The next near-term PCI driver using IIDC can also this. Why expose the whole PF? This is a design choice no? Why do we need to follow mlx5? > > You can see it clearly based on how this gets initialized: > > cdev_info->pdev = pf->pdev; > cdev_info->hw_addr = (u8 __iomem *)pf->hw.hw_addr; > > struct ice_vsi *vsi = ice_get_main_vsi(pf); > cdev_info->vport_id = vsi->vsi_num; > cdev_info->netdev = vsi->netdev; > cdev_info->msix_count = pf->num_rdma_msix; > cdev_info->msix_entries = &pf->msix_entries[pf- > >rdma_base_vector]; > > ice_setup_dcb_qos_info(pf, cdev_info->qos_info); > > Since the main place this cdev_info appears is in the ops API between the two > modules, it looks to me like this is being designed in this obfuscated way to try > and create a stable ABI between two modules. > > Remove all the stable module ABI hackery before you resend it. > I don't follow what the hackery is. Just because we use cdev_info in the .ops callbacks as opposed to ice_pf? This is a private interface for Intel RDMA/PCI drivers and yes it is designed to be forward looking especially since when we have near-term plans to use it. Can you explain what you mean by stable module ABI hackery? Shiraz
On Mon, Apr 12, 2021 at 02:51:18PM +0000, Saleem, Shiraz wrote: > > Where is ftype initialized? > > Today it is just pf. But the upcoming Intel ethernet VF driver will > set it to true. Then it is dead code, don't send dead code to the kernel. > > This cdev_info should just be a 'struct ice_pf *' and the "struct > > iidc_core_dev_info" should be deleted entirely. You'll notice this > > ends up looking nearly exactly like mlx5 does after this. > > It was intentionally designed to be core device object carving out > only pieces of the PF information required by the rdma driver. The > next near-term PCI driver using IIDC can also this. Why expose the > whole PF? This is a design choice no? Why do we need to follow mlx5? When you get around to building your multi-driver API it should be structured so it doesn't have a de-normalization of the data - don't copy from one authoritative struct to some other struct just to get some weird information hiding. The PF driver should be a subclass if your "generic" driver and directly embed some struct like this as the singular canonical source of information, not be duplicated. > I don't follow what the hackery is. Just because we use cdev_info in > the .ops callbacks as opposed to ice_pf? There are too many signs to ignore: - The obfuscated extensible structs being passed into ops that are only encoding a couple function call parameters - The ops that only have one implementation - The struct that is a complete copy of a different, but "internal", struct You do stuff like this to make stable ABIs. This is forbidden by Linus for in-kernel APIs, and it is not the kernel style in general to code like this. Jason
diff --git a/MAINTAINERS b/MAINTAINERS index a1e3502..27e424e 100644 --- a/MAINTAINERS +++ b/MAINTAINERS @@ -8955,6 +8955,7 @@ F: Documentation/networking/device_drivers/ethernet/intel/ F: drivers/net/ethernet/intel/ F: drivers/net/ethernet/intel/*/ F: include/linux/avf/virtchnl.h +F: include/linux/net/intel/iidc.h INTEL FRAMEBUFFER DRIVER (excluding 810 and 815) M: Maik Broemme <mbroemme@libmpq.org> diff --git a/include/linux/net/intel/iidc.h b/include/linux/net/intel/iidc.h new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2c360c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/include/linux/net/intel/iidc.h @@ -0,0 +1,242 @@ +/* SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0 */ +/* Copyright (C) 2021, Intel Corporation. */ + +#ifndef _IIDC_H_ +#define _IIDC_H_ + +#include <linux/auxiliary_bus.h> +#include <linux/dcbnl.h> +#include <linux/device.h> +#include <linux/if_ether.h> +#include <linux/kernel.h> +#include <linux/netdevice.h> + +enum iidc_event_type { + IIDC_EVENT_BEFORE_MTU_CHANGE, + IIDC_EVENT_AFTER_MTU_CHANGE, + IIDC_EVENT_BEFORE_TC_CHANGE, + IIDC_EVENT_AFTER_TC_CHANGE, + IIDC_EVENT_DSCP_MAP_CHANGE, + IIDC_EVENT_CRIT_ERR, + IIDC_EVENT_NBITS /* must be last */ +}; + +enum iidc_res_type { + IIDC_INVAL_RES, + IIDC_VSI, + IIDC_VEB, + IIDC_EVENT_Q, + IIDC_EGRESS_CMPL_Q, + IIDC_CMPL_EVENT_Q, + IIDC_ASYNC_EVENT_Q, + IIDC_DOORBELL_Q, + IIDC_RDMA_QSETS_TXSCHED, +}; + +enum iidc_reset_type { + IIDC_PFR, + IIDC_CORER, + IIDC_GLOBR, +}; + +enum iidc_rdma_protocol { + IIDC_RDMA_PROTOCOL_IWARP, + IIDC_RDMA_PROTOCOL_ROCEV2, +}; + +/* Struct to hold per DCB APP info */ +struct iidc_dcb_app_info { + u8 priority; + u8 selector; + u16 prot_id; +}; + +struct iidc_core_dev_info; + +#define IIDC_MAX_USER_PRIORITY 8 +#define IIDC_MAX_APPS 72 +#define IIDC_MAX_DSCP_MAPPING 64 + +/* Struct to hold per RDMA Qset info */ +struct iidc_rdma_qset_params { + u32 teid; /* Qset TEID */ + u16 qs_handle; /* RDMA driver provides this */ + u16 vport_id; /* VSI index */ + u8 tc; /* TC branch the Qset should belong to */ + u8 reserved[3]; +}; + +struct iidc_res_base { + /* Union for future provision e.g. other res_type */ + union { + struct iidc_rdma_qset_params qsets; + } res; +}; + +struct iidc_res { + /* Type of resource. */ + enum iidc_res_type res_type; + /* Count requested */ + u16 cnt_req; + + /* Number of resources allocated. Filled in by callee. + * Based on this value, caller to fill up "resources" + */ + u16 res_allocated; + + /* Unique handle to resources allocated. Zero if call fails. + * Allocated by callee and for now used by caller for internal + * tracking purpose. + */ + u32 res_handle; + + /* Peer driver has to allocate sufficient memory, to accommodate + * cnt_requested before calling this function. + * Memory has to be zero initialized. It is input/output param. + * As a result of alloc_res API, this structures will be populated. + */ + struct iidc_res_base res[1]; +}; + +struct iidc_qos_info { + u64 tc_ctx; + u8 rel_bw; + u8 prio_type; + u8 egress_virt_up; + u8 ingress_virt_up; +}; + +struct iidc_dscp_map { + u16 dscp_val; + u8 tc; +}; + +/* Struct to hold QoS info */ +struct iidc_qos_params { + struct iidc_qos_info tc_info[IEEE_8021QAZ_MAX_TCS]; + u8 up2tc[IIDC_MAX_USER_PRIORITY]; + u8 vport_relative_bw; + u8 vport_priority_type; + u32 num_apps; + struct iidc_dcb_app_info apps[IIDC_MAX_APPS]; + struct iidc_dscp_map dscp_maps[IIDC_MAX_DSCP_MAPPING]; + u8 num_tc; +}; + +union iidc_event_info { + /* IIDC_EVENT_AFTER_TC_CHANGE */ + struct iidc_qos_params port_qos; + /* IIDC_EVENT_CRIT_ERR */ + u32 reg; +}; + +struct iidc_event { + DECLARE_BITMAP(type, IIDC_EVENT_NBITS); + union iidc_event_info info; +}; + +/* Following APIs are implemented by core PCI driver */ +struct iidc_core_ops { + /* APIs to allocate resources such as VEB, VSI, Doorbell queues, + * completion queues, Tx/Rx queues, etc... + */ + int (*alloc_res)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, + struct iidc_res *res, + int partial_acceptable); + int (*free_res)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, + struct iidc_res *res); + + int (*request_reset)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, + enum iidc_reset_type reset_type); + + int (*update_vport_filter)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, + u16 vport_id, bool enable); + int (*vc_send)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, u32 vf_id, u8 *msg, + u16 len); +}; + +/* Following APIs are implemented by auxiliary drivers and invoked by core PCI + * driver + */ +struct iidc_auxiliary_ops { + /* This event_handler is meant to be a blocking call. For instance, + * when a BEFORE_MTU_CHANGE event comes in, the event_handler will not + * return until the auxiliary driver is ready for the MTU change to + * happen. + */ + void (*event_handler)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, + struct iidc_event *event); + + int (*vc_receive)(struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info, u32 vf_id, + u8 *msg, u16 len); +}; + +#define IIDC_RDMA_NAME "intel_rdma" +#define IIDC_RDMA_ID 0x00000010 +#define IIDC_MAX_NUM_AUX 4 + +/* The const struct that instantiates cdev_info_id needs to be initialized + * in the .c with the macro ASSIGN_IIDC_INFO. + * For example: + * static const struct cdev_info_id cdev_info_ids[] = ASSIGN_IIDC_INFO; + */ +struct cdev_info_id { + char *name; + int id; +}; + +#define IIDC_RDMA_INFO { .name = IIDC_RDMA_NAME, .id = IIDC_RDMA_ID }, + +#define ASSIGN_IIDC_INFO \ +{ \ + IIDC_RDMA_INFO \ +} + +#define iidc_priv(x) ((x)->auxiliary_priv) + +/* Structure representing auxiliary driver tailored information about the core + * PCI dev, each auxiliary driver using the IIDC interface will have an + * instance of this struct dedicated to it. + */ +struct iidc_core_dev_info { + struct pci_dev *pdev; /* PCI device of corresponding to main function */ + struct auxiliary_device *adev; + /* KVA / Linear address corresponding to BAR0 of underlying + * pci_device. + */ + u8 __iomem *hw_addr; + int cdev_info_id; + + u8 ftype; /* PF(false) or VF (true) */ + + u16 vport_id; + enum iidc_rdma_protocol rdma_protocol; + + struct iidc_qos_params qos_info; + struct net_device *netdev; + + struct msix_entry *msix_entries; + u16 msix_count; /* How many vectors are reserved for this device */ + + /* Following struct contains function pointers to be initialized + * by core PCI driver and called by auxiliary driver + */ + const struct iidc_core_ops *ops; +}; + +struct iidc_auxiliary_dev { + struct auxiliary_device adev; + struct iidc_core_dev_info *cdev_info; +}; + +/* structure representing the auxiliary driver. This struct is to be + * allocated and populated by the auxiliary driver's owner. The core PCI + * driver will access these ops by performing a container_of on the + * auxiliary_device->dev.driver. + */ +struct iidc_auxiliary_drv { + struct auxiliary_driver adrv; + struct iidc_auxiliary_ops *ops; +}; + +#endif /* _IIDC_H_*/